Votes are a signal, not a plan.
The most-voted list is a great place to start a decision and a bad place to finish one.
Nº 05 · HeedPost team · Sep 2, 2026 · 2 min read
It's tempting to run a product off the top of the board. Sort by votes, build the first thing, ship, repeat. It feels fair, it's easy to explain, and customers can see their votes doing something.
It also quietly hands your roadmap to whoever is best at rallying votes.
What a vote actually measures
A vote measures that a person saw a post and agreed with it enough to press a button. That's real information. But notice everything it leaves out:
- Whether the voter would pay more, stay longer, or tell a friend because of it.
- How often they'd use it. A daily annoyance and a once-a-year wish count the same.
- Who saw the post at all. Old posts collect votes simply by having been there longer.
- Who didn't vote. Most of your customers never visit your board.
None of that makes votes useless. It makes them one signal among several.
What to put next to the count
Before a request reaches the top of your plan, look at a few other things alongside the votes.
Who's asking. Ten votes from your largest customers and ten from free trials that never converted are different weights. You don't need to ignore small customers to notice this.
What it costs. A request with forty votes that takes a day might deserve to go before one with two hundred that takes a quarter.
What it's for. Some requests fit where the product is going. Some pull it sideways. Votes can't tell you which is which. You have to decide that.
What changed recently. A request that's rising fast is telling you something about right now.
Be honest about how you decide
Customers don't need you to build the top request. They need to understand why you didn't. If you say plainly that you weigh votes alongside who's asking and what it takes to build, most people accept a decision that isn't simply the highest number. What breaks trust is a board that implies "vote and we'll build it" and then doesn't.
A sentence near the top of your board helps: "We read every post and weigh votes alongside effort and fit. We'll always tell you where a request stands."
Keep voting cheap, and keep it real
Votes are only useful if they're honest, so protect them. One vote per person. No buying votes with discounts. And when you merge duplicates, make sure every voter is counted once, not twice.
The board is where customers tell you what hurts. The plan is where you decide what to do about it. Keep those two jobs separate and both get better.